The race for New York’s 22nd Congressional District has become one of the most closely watched contests in the state as Republican incumbent Brandon Williams faces Democratic state Sen. John Mannion. With recent redistricting making it slightly more Democratic, both candidates are vying for votes in a battle that could help decide control of the U.S. House of Representatives.

Economic priorities and jobs

Economic concerns are foremost for both candidates, but their approaches differ greatly. Mannion points to his record in the New York State Senate, particularly his work on “Green Chips” legislation, which he claims brought tens of thousands of jobs to the region through a massive investment by Micron. He advocates for additional federal investment in infrastructure and workforce training programs to build a high-tech economy in central New York.

Williams, a former Navy officer and business owner, focuses his economic message on cutting government spending and cutting taxes. He criticizes what he describes as “reckless” spending in Washington, linking it to inflation. Williams promotes energy independence and opposes policies like the Green New Deal, which he argues would hurt middle-class families by raising costs and hurting industries that provide jobs in his district.

Public safety and crime

When it comes to public safety, Williams and Mannion have contrasting priorities. Williams highlights his support for increased funding for police and law enforcement, positioning himself as tough on crime. He criticizes New York’s no-cash bail law, which he blames for increasing the crime rate, and calls for its repeal to keep “dangerous criminals off the streets.”

Mannion, however, is focused on community policing and public safety investments that include mental health support for law enforcement. He secured funding for local police departments and fire services during his time in the state senate. Mannion says his approach not only addresses immediate safety concerns, but also builds trust and cooperation within communities.

Health care and social issues

Healthcare is another point of divergence. Mannion, who helped expand health care coverage in the state, plans to push for further expansion of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) if elected to Congress. He supports measures to cap drug prices, increase access to mental health services and make health care more affordable for low-income families. As a former science teacher, he also supports public health initiatives, including funding for opioid crisis interventions.

Williams, while advocating for improved health care for veterans, criticizes federal overreach in health care. He opposes universal health care and insists that health care should remain a statewide issue. Williams supports measures to reduce health care costs, but frames his approach as rooted in maintaining existing private insurance options rather than expanding federal programs.

Reproductive rights and women’s issues

The candidates’ positions on abortion and reproductive rights show a clear ideological divide. Mannion, endorsed by Planned Parenthood, supports codifying Roe v. Wade into federal law through the Women’s Health Protection Act and opposes any federal restrictions on abortion. He advocates for protecting access to contraception and ensuring that decisions about women’s health remain between patients and doctors.

Williams, who identifies as pro-life, opposes federal abortion bans and believes decisions about reproductive rights should remain at the state level. He emphasizes supporting women facing difficult pregnancies through expanded adoption services and resources for mothers, rather than legislative bans.

Immigration and Border Security

On immigration, Williams takes a hard line, criticizing the Biden administration’s border policies and stressing the need for increased border security. He calls for stricter enforcement of immigration laws and supports strengthening Customs and Border Protection.

Mannion, while advocating for border security, emphasizes a more comprehensive approach. He supports bipartisan solutions to address immigration reform, such as increasing border staffing and improving the asylum process. Mannion advocates for a fair and humane system that respects immigrants while ensuring safety and compliance with the law.

Education and the Environment

Mannion’s background as a former public school teacher shapes his educational platform. He supports expanding federal funding for schools, raising teacher pay and providing universal pre-K. Mannion also advocates for investment in renewable energy and environmental protection, including measures to combat climate change and guarantee clean water.

Williams focuses on reducing federal influence in education, arguing for parental controls and transparency in school programs. He opposes what he calls “radical government mandates” in education, particularly on issues related to gender identity and sexual orientation. On the environment, he rejects policies such as the Green New Deal, arguing that they are financially burdensome and harmful to energy independence.

A Battle for a Swing Neighborhood

As the candidates campaign across the district, they highlight their differences while appealing to voters in a swing district that could determine the direction of Congress. With national organizations pouring resources into the race and Williams labeled one of the most vulnerable Republican incumbents, the outcome in New York’s 22nd district could have a significant impact on the party that controls the US House of Representatives after Election Day.

FingerLakes1.com is the region’s leading digital news publication. The company was founded in 1998 and has been keeping residents informed for more than two decades. Do you have a track? Send it to (email protected).